Aaron Judge Garrett Crochet refers to a genuinely well-documented on-field rivalry between the Yankees’ star slugger and the Red Sox ace pitcher whose surname happens to match the craft, one of the more closely watched individual matchups in recent Yankees-Red Sox history. This matchup consistently delivered exactly the drama sports commentary promised through the 2025 season. This guide covers the real, documented history between the two.
The Real Matchup History
Through the 2025 regular season, Crochet largely got the better of Judge across their head-to-head at-bats, striking him out ten times in fifteen plate appearances while Judge managed only two hits, both home runs, including a dramatic ninth-inning shot that denied Crochet a complete-game shutout in one June matchup. Despite the lopsided strikeout numbers, Judge gave Crochet significant public credit, describing him as the best pitcher in the game following their October Wild Card series encounter.
The 2025 Wild Card Series Showdown
The two faced off in Game 1 of the American League Wild Card Series in October 2025, with Crochet delivering a dominant 7 and two-thirds innings, allowing just one run and striking out 11 Yankees, including Judge himself. Boston won that game 3-1, with Crochet’s performance widely covered as one of the standout individual pitching efforts of the postseason.
Why This Matchup Draws So Much Attention
Beyond the surname coincidence with the craft, the matchup itself genuinely earns its hype: Judge is one of the most feared power hitters in the sport, and Crochet’s ability to consistently contain him became a defining storyline of the 2025 Yankees-Red Sox rivalry specifically.
Frequently asked questions
Who has won more head-to-head matchups, Judge or Crochet?
Through the 2025 season, Crochet got the better of Judge in the large majority of their matchups, striking him out ten times across fifteen plate appearances, though Judge’s two hits against him were both home runs.
What did Aaron Judge say about Garrett Crochet?
Following their October 2025 Wild Card series matchup, Judge publicly called Crochet the best pitcher in the game, praising his performance after a dominant start that helped Boston win Game 1.
Want the Red Sox rotation context too?
See Garrett Crochet’s current 2026 status and rotation situation.
See the current rotation update
